Skip to content

Comparing explanations

Historians test a theory by asking how much of the evidence it explains — and how much it has to explain away. Here are the most common explanations for what happened after Jesus died, set against the facts.

ExplanationDeathEmpty tombPaulJamesDisciplesOther witnessesBoldnessGrowthScore
ResurrectionExplainsExplainsExplainsExplainsExplainsExplainsExplainsExplains8/8
SwoonDoes not explainPartly / strainedDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explain0/8
ConspiracyExplainsExplainsDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainPartly / strained2/8
HallucinationExplainsDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainPartly / strainedDoes not explainPartly / strainedPartly / strained1/8
LegendExplainsDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainPartly / strained1/8
Wrong tombExplainsExplainsDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explainDoes not explain2/8
UnknownNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offeredNo explanation offered0/8
✓ explains~ partly or with strain✕ does not explain? offers no explanationThe best explanation will account for all the evidence.

Jesus actually rose from the dead, as His followers claimed.

Jesus did not really die on the cross; He revived in the tomb.

The disciples stole the body and invented the story.

The disciples experienced grief-induced visions.

The story grew over time and the early facts were lost.

The women and disciples went to the wrong tomb and found it empty.

“Something happened, but we can’t say what.” This is honest — but it is not an explanation.